Poverty. The answer is always poverty. Evacuation is not free and never has been.

Currently sitting in the Tampa Bay area while a category 5+ hurricane comes barreling at me. I’m in flood zone D next to E so I shouldn’t have any issues there. In a building that is solid brick/cinderblock construction, built like a bunker. Don’t worry about me. I got water, food, and enough fat to get me through the winter as they say.

The one thing I don’t have is the hundreds or thousands of dollars it would take to drive 2+ states away and get a hotel for a week. I simply don’t have it. Then you have all these people in places like Missouri or Montana posting this question about why people would not evacuate. We don’t have the goddamn money. It’s not hubris. We SHOULD evacuate. I don’t see any of the people saying this offering up a spot on their couch. We should always evacuate… somewhere other than the house of the person who thinks we should, apparently.

  • hypercracker@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    63
    ·
    1 month ago

    Yeah people have this idea that the government actually does jack shit except for being like “hey leave the area or you’re gonna die, sucks to be you lol” maybe they think they’re working to set up thousands of people in stadiums or whatever, and sometimes that does happen, but overwhelmingly it’s just telling people to spend over a months’ rent to stay at a hotel with surge pricing.

    • FlakesBongler [they/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      54
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      1 month ago

      I literally had an argument with someone who thought that they send in buses and helicopters to take people out of their homes

      I was like “Maybe in other countries, but here, you’re lucky if the cops don’t shoot at you and say you were a looter”

          • came_apart_at_Kmart [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            40
            ·
            edit-2
            1 month ago

            they do it in Cuba. there’s a whole organized civil service that is called up for extreme weather to help people, families, those with disabilities, the elderly, to evacuate with their necessities, medications, and pets into secured housing locations when the order is given. there is no “report to work anyway” going on except emergency services and community organization.

            Jacobin did an article on it some years ago. should be easy to find.

            Cuba has it worked out despite being very much isolated and forcibly kept impoverished in the same area as hurricanes bring destruction, it is rare as hell for someone to die there due to a hurricane… unlike every western allied nation and state in the region, where people get killed just about every time, sometimes many people.

            the statistics are and should be one of the most obvious embarrassments and failures of capitalist ideology, but nobody in the US learns about any of this. ever.

            found it: https://jacobin.com/2017/08/hurricane-harvey-cuba-disaster-plan

            • Frank [he/him, he/him]@hexbear.net
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              21
              ·
              1 month ago

              If I understand it every single person in the country has a designated shelter and orders on what they’re supposed to do, who they help, and so forth for disasters. It’s unbelievable, it could never happen in the us.

              Makes me think of the Soviet Metros. The Moscow Metro was built far, far deeper and far larger than it needed to be, partially because it was built to be beautiful because useful things should be beautiful, but also so it could accomodate enormous numbers of people if the Americans attacked. The Soviets sat down and said “how can we build enough shelters for everyone?” And then did their best.

              America never built large scale public shelters partially because the government thought it was too communist and partially because they figured the cities were acceptable casualties and the us-foreign-policy people who lived there us-foreign-policy were acceptable losses.

              • yeah, it’s pretty clear they could give a fuck about any of us. however, i have no doubt there is enough space for the wealthy and powerful via “continuity of government” infrastructure which is all, of course, highly classified from all us dumbass citizens because why would we need to know where to go during a disaster? after a big enough mass casualty event, they would just relax, reshape, and contract border and naturalization policy at whatever rate wouldn’t overwhelm the containment and fragmentation of class consciousness.

      • SorosFootSoldier [he/him, they/them]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        25
        ·
        1 month ago

        I literally had an argument with someone who thought that they send in buses and helicopters to take people out of their homes

        That would require the government to help poor people and helping poor people is communism, sweetie.

      • ColeSloth@discuss.tchncs.de
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        1 month ago

        They do. In Florida right now they have free busses to remove people and free storm shelters set up to take them to. Even special needs/ health accommodations.

    • SorosFootSoldier [he/him, they/them]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      25
      ·
      1 month ago

      yeonmi-park And in bad country the poor working class can’t afford to evacuate so they die in the storm. The survivors go out to find food and water, because the government can’t provide because they wasted all the federal funds on bombing Palestine, and they get shot by a navy seal sniper with PTSD.

  • abc [he/him, comrade/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    39
    ·
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    That’s right.

    Always think of this great (rare) FB post back from when Florence hit NC as it sums up exactly this.

    Two nights ago I called Alyeesha – a friend of a friend who had stayed at my house a few years ago when she was escaping a bad relationship. She lives Down East, back in her hometown in Carteret County, in a small one-room house that was her grandma’s sharecropping cabin. She rents the cabin from the man who now owns the land; it is not hers. I’ve been there once. She had a mattress on the floor, a sofa from a Rent-a-Center, and a picture of her grandmother on the wall. I wanted to let her know that if she was evacuating from the hurricane, there was a sofa waiting for her here.

    “Naw, I’m going to ride it out,” she said.

    Everyone I know Down East and on the shore is riding it out. For a few it’s bravado, but for most of them, it’s… it’s just that they can’t go. There aren’t enough seats in the car, or there is no car, or the car is busted. There are too many babies or too many old folks. There are jobs that won’t be held for them if they can’t make it back in a few days; there are paychecks that haven’t yet cleared; there are food stamps that ran out last week. And there isn’t enough money in anyone’s damn bank account.

    But you know, we all love a good hurricane. We fetishize storms. We are glued to our televisions and we are refreshing our screens. We talk about the wind speed, we marvel at the tattered piers. It’s almost like we want it. Truth is, I think Alyeesha and all my friends are going to be just fine during this hurricane. After all, as terrifying as it is, we know it’s not Florence that is wreaking havoc on North Carolina. It’s everything that comes later; it’s everything after the storm; it’s everything that was before.

    We know that it is the slow seep of the water back down from the mountains, spreading itself out of its riverbed path, breaking itself out the creeks and cricks, rushing itself off the pavement of the cities and going Down East. It’s water swallowing up crops and homes and pigs – we know this slow seep and we know that it is not just water; we know it is poverty.

    The hurricane is the drama, the excitement that we need. We gather bottled water, toilet paper, snacks. It’s something we can do, something we can prepare for. We like the idea of bracing ourselves against wind; we feel enraptured, intoxicated, instinctual, alive. Our lives can be so mundane. So we watch, we watch, we watch. We gorge on hurricanes.

    But the flood that we know is coming is something to look away from; something we try not to speak of. It is smeared red clay up living room walls. It’s stalled out Buicks getting their last rust. It’s somebody’s work tools sinking into the river. It’s humid air plastering an old Myrtle Beach t-shirt onto a body as it shovels filthy toys into trash bags. It is mud and muck and poverty. And we know it is coming. It is all very predictable. And we will look away.

    Poverty has always been a flood and not a hurricane. It’s always been a slow rolling disaster, with muddy gray water under an incongruent bright blue sky. It’s always been a slow build of mold between generations, of people making do with babies in faded red milk crates being floated on mattresses down city streets. Look away.

    Poverty is slow. It’s a looming light bill and a long wait on child support. It’s the uncomfortable plastic chairs at DSS and the caseworkers who don’t make eye contact. It’s the ten months of pregnancy with no insurance and lying to the doctor about the cramps because you can’t afford a referral. It’s the long wait in jail because you can’t afford bail and long Christmas days when you can’t afford presents. It’s the long nights with the heat out and the long calls trying to reach the landlord. It’s the hours in detention after your own boss at the meat processing plant calls immigration on you and the long stare you give him while he hires your cousin for less money under the table. Sometimes poverty is even the long last minutes trying to get through the locked door at the Hamlet Chicken Plant. So we look away.

    Poverty is predictable. It’s the predictability of underfunded schools and outdated textbooks. It’s the predictability of an entire two generations of fathers and mothers being locked up and their left-behind children staring cold-eyed and speaking tight-lipped during the Pledge at school. It’s the predictability of legislators turning their heads and hog waste and coal ash breaching levees. It’s the predictability that after the storm we will arrest the looters who spent their last dollars on gas when prices surged up 50 cents before the storm. The predictability of all this makes us look like fools, like forty-something men wanting twenty-something wives. And we are embarrassed by it all. We will look away and not say a thing.

    We don’t have to look because we know where the flood waters will go. They will follow a slow, predictable path. We know who lives in low lying areas, we know what neighborhoods are south of the tracks. From Appalachia down, every town has Hillers and Creekers and floodplains read like economic and racial maps.

    Alyeesha has the grit to make it through the storm, but after the winds pass and the bottled water gets loaded back up, she knows that people’s attention will just move on. Jim Cantore does not come for poverty.

    Alyeesha’s little house may be flooded out, she may lose everything. There is no insurance company to call; her landlord may just tell her he can’t do nothing, just move along. Her friend who drives her to work may not be able to come to get her, she may lose her job. She will be left standing in the still waters of America, brown water on her brown legs, on land that was not her grandmothers and is not hers, with no place but my sofa to go.

    But that’s the predictable slow drip of poverty. All your life you are just watching the water rise, knowing no one is coming to get you: after all, they told you to get out.

    https://www.facebook.com/gwenskeptical/posts/pfbid02p7mPmZqXLVSkt1WN3ZNgsN3W3XhoksT3qtNJ3Xz8FgeS9Dsu56gr14XPZ9XL2NbCl

    • Hmm [none/use name]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      27
      ·
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      To be clear I’m not singling out this comment by replying to it. A lot of other ones in this thread are saying similar things. This one is just near the top right now so I’m replying to it for visibility.

      I don’t want anyone in the area getting killed because of incorrect doomposting. There are some services still available to help people evacuate.

      From the Pinellas County website: https://pinellas.gov/news/pinellas-county-issues-mandatory-evacuation-orders-for-zones-a-b-c-and-mobile-homes/

      Pinellas County has issued mandatory evacuation orders for all residents in evacuation zones A, B and C and all mobile home residents countywide, effective immediately, today, Monday, Oct. 7.

      To support evacuations, the County has announced the opening of six emergency shelters, including shelters for people with special needs and pet-friendly shelters (see full list below).

      The County previously announced mandatory evacuation orders for long-term care facilities, assisted living facilities and hospitals, and special needs residents in evacuation zones A, B and C. The County is also recommending that special needs residents in evacuation zones D and E evacuate due to the potential loss of electricity and water.

      PSTA is offering free rides to the shelters 24/7, effective from now until conditions become unsafe for buses to be on the road. Pets are allowed on the bus: dogs and cats in a crate, large dogs on a muzzle leash. For the latest information on PSTA bus service, call the InfoLine at (727) 540-1900.

      Residents who don’t know their evacuation zone can check it here.

      Barrier islands info

      The Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office will be patrolling the barrier islands from Sand Key south to Pass-a-Grille and announcing the mandatory evacuation. PSTA will provide free transportation on regular bus routes or for anyone who is able to signal a passing bus or trolley.

      I checked and the other two counties on Tampa Bay have similar services for transporting people to shelters:

      Edit:

      I’ve created a thread to gather Hurricane Milton resources to help people: https://hexbear.net/post/3632288

      And for completeness here’s evacuation transportation assistance info for the other county expecting 10-15 feet of storm surge:

  • Mog_Pharou [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    36
    ·
    1 month ago

    Also in Tampa and not leaving. Be safe comrade stalin-heart

    I would have to stay no matter what to staff a local hospital, but I’m not in any evacuation zone and my condo is also a bunker. So i know I’ll be ok, at worse uncomfortable. Honestly glad it’s hitting us and not Cuba.

  • Zvyozdochka [she/her, pup/pup's]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    34
    ·
    1 month ago

    Currently sitting in the Tampa Bay area while a category 5+ hurricane comes barreling at me. I’m in flood zone D next to E so I shouldn’t have any issues there

    Stay safe comrade heart-sickle hope you don’t get hit too hard

    • LaughingLion [any, any]@hexbear.netOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      31
      ·
      1 month ago

      We’ve been through a few hurricanes here. I’ve endured 1+ week without power and internet before in this very apartment I’m in right now. It does suck to be stuck without modern comforts in a tropical area but at least it isn’t August. We’ll survive.

      I’m making some garlic bread on an everything bagel for me and my wife to snack on right now. Going to do laundry at the laundrymat in a few I think that’s what people don’t get is everything is so domestic and normal right up until the winds start really hitting.

  • UlyssesT [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    25
    ·
    1 month ago

    I admit that where I am living now that if there were a sudden imminent disaster on its way, I really can’t afford to move or even to evacuate, even for a few days.

    I think it’s a lowkey libbrain thing to automatically assume anyone that doesn’t evacuate is just voluntarily being stubborn and smug.

      • UlyssesT [he/him]@hexbear.net
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        20
        ·
        1 month ago

        how-much-could-it-cost “It’s just like how you never go out and live. That’s your problem and that’s why you’re poor: you don’t open yourself to new experiences like authentic Turkish tea from an authentic Turkish tea house…”

    • Frank [he/him, he/him]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      1 month ago

      Word. And there isn’t really anywhere to go. I have so much water treatment gear. Nothing fancy, just passive filters, but i could probably manage a few hundred gallons before the camp filter gave up. All bc, Idk if my neighbors have any. It’s just camping filters, but it’s big camping filters and hopefully if things ever get really bad it can get some folks through. : (

  • Beaver [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    21
    ·
    1 month ago

    Glad you’re preparing. I used to live in the Caribbean, and we never evacuated for hurricanes because there simply wasn’t anywhere to go. Storm surge is the big killer, so I’m glad you’re out of that danger.

    One thing to make sure you have some cash on hand (ironic advice given the title of the thread, I know). As stores re-open, they’ll invariably have trouble with their electronic payment systems.

  • PurrLure [she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    1 month ago

    While there are free shelters, those tend to fill up pretty quickly. There’s also a guilt associated with calling them for help if you have a secure place to stay, since homeless people and those with vulnerable mobile homes/trailers/RVs are among those that need them the most.

    Most people would absolutely need to bust out the credit card and go into debt to evacuate, and go even further into debt if they want a place where their car doesn’t risk getting flooded. While it’s illegal to jack up prices for water and gas during a hurricane, as far as I’ve seen hotels are usually free game, especially as we’re getting closer to the holiday season. If anyone even bothers to report them later, they can just say they were planning on raising prices for Halloween events anyway. Add in the fact that many people don’t get paid time off, so that’s an extra couple of days of lost wages. Yesterday would have been the day to say fuck it and whip out your card, as I imagine today that the cheapest and safest Airbnb/hotels are all booked up. Surely many of them were already half booked with tourists, since many tourism guides say you can avoid hurricanes as long as you visit in the fall. (Hurricane season actually ends Nov 30th, a fact that might become much more relevant in the next few years.) Canceling toll charges is obviously pennies compared to the rest of the cost, anyone that acts like that’s enough is a deeply unserious individual.

    The roads will probably be pretty clogged if you travel north today. I do feel a little bad for saying not to travel south yesterday, as some people on here have gone that route. They probably won’t deal with as much traffic as they would have been otherwise. My anxiety insists that you’re cornering yourself traveling south, but honestly as long as you’re mainland and not next door to a swamp, you’re probably safe. Good luck with gas if you’re out on the road today. Being stuck in your car during a hurricane is a nightmare that I hope no one here experiences.

    If there’s one silver lining of the storm, it’s that the heat is actually pretty manageable. Heat stroke should be way down compared to a normal Aug/Sept hurricane. It might even cause repairs and the power to come back quicker if workers are just a little less exhausted working 12 hour days outside. Prep extra ice for your fridge and fill your bathtubs with water tomorrow. Good luck out there.

    • LaughingLion [any, any]@hexbear.netOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      6
      ·
      1 month ago

      All true. One thing to note, all the hotels and airbnbs were booked up 3 days ago. Not just the cheapest ones. ALL of them and pretty much every one of them were 2x or more the price.

      We’ll ride it out. We’ll get through. I’m in a safe place from surge and winds.

  • Frogmanfromlake [none/use name]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    1 month ago

    This happened with me when Beryl struck my town. It’s a little easier to relocate here because the government hasn’t quite been able to penetrate the rural areas, which makes it easier to just abandon your home and leave without having to deal with any legal issues. But money will still play a part when you want to find a job in your new town and the nearby areas are pretty poor as well. You would need to spend more money to move up further north where people tend to be more elitist towards those from the more rural areas, especially if they lack money.

    Most of us don’t want to deal with that hassle and so we took the hurricane head-on and dealt with the aftermath ourselves. The town still hasn’t fully recovered since then and I fear for the next round of hurricanes we’ll have to weather.

  • AssortedBiscuits [they/them]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    1 month ago

    Then you have all these people in places like Missouri or Montana posting this question about why people would not evacuate. We don’t have the goddamn money.

    They need to put their money where their mouth is. I don’t see them donating money to Floridan Gofundmes or Paypals.

    Money talks. Bullshit walks. Put up or shut up.