starkillerfish (she)

  • 3 Posts
  • 39 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: September 3rd, 2023

help-circle








  • Also consider that there may be people (perhaps like yourself) who don’t agree but just don’t speak up.

    My thoughts exactly. I don’t think you are going to find people who walk around with a red star pin on campus (I do but im a weirdo), but @[email protected] can definitely find people who are more sympathetic to socialist ideas. I find anti-imperialism to be a very good topic for that for instance. Maybe i’m optimistic about Canada but I’ve met socialists in the most conservative areas of the US, so anything is possible.




  • He went on to explain that because of the famine many Ukrainians had their nationalism fuelled and sided with the Nazis.

    except that many many many more Ukrainians were fighting on the side of the soviet union.

    I tried to explain away my motivations because I am not about to put a target on my back with the school.

    don’t you already have a target on your back by writing about donbas and being openly marxist with some professors? i mean to say that you might be more open with your politics than you give yourself credit.






  • This is a very complex question because Russians are not homogeneous in their opinions of the west. Speaking from personal experience from people I know and on social media: I would say there are three major groups:

    • People who really don’t care. Mostly older population or people outside major population centers. A lot of people just aren’t polarized the same way people are in the west.
    • People who want to be like the west. These are usually more upper-class city people (Moscow, St. Petersburg) who consume western media and products, go on vacations to Europe. Also a lot of younger people with good english. This group wants better civil liberties (ala USA), more integration with western organisations (for travel an commerce).
    • Then there are people who think the west is awful and Russia is the bastion of wholesome family (christian orthodox) values. They see the problems in the western world, but (without marxist analysis) attribute it to ‘multiculturalism’ and lgbt people. Similar to how right wing groups in the west present the issues.

    I would also say that it is mostly unchanged since 2022, maybe just more solidified. There was definitely a shift in 2014, because afterwards the Russian government saw that they cannot cooperate with the west and at the same time maintain their status as a regional power. So since then there was more of a push in the media towards anti western views.

    This is what I can think of off the top of my head. Would be happy to answer any follow up questions the best i can




  • I agree with the MicrophoneFiend that these are all deep and diverse topics. For question 2 I would recommend Socialism Betrayed: Behind the Collapse of the Soviet Union by Roger Keeran & Thomas Kenny.

    Also keep in mind for questions 1 and 3 that the soviet union existed from 1922 to 1991, conditions and the economy varied immensely. you would have to be more precise which period you are interested in.