• 1 Post
  • 849 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 8th, 2023

help-circle
  • I wouldn’t call central planning “Marxist”, it’s just better for many things. And Marxism is about trying to find the best solutions scientifically to the issue of capitalism. Namely a revolution and a restructuring of society by the workers “in their image”. And practice of attempting that and building that new society brought new innovations and ideas.

    Also, the end goal for Marxists, like for all communists, is and should be a “stateless, moneyless, classless society”. Not in any “words mean different things” way. In a “there is no more class divisions, no more commodity production and capital, and no more state or hierarchical authority. Like anarchists want as well.


  • That is incredibly naive. Just look at history. Fascists were always defeated by violent resistance. And nothing else.

    Those who claimed to fight them peacefully all shut up right when they got into power and only quietly showed their discontent behind closed doors, while they kept on living under the fascists. Many even came to support the fascists after it wasn’t so uncouth to do so…

    The people who were afraid of doing anything real at first, but certainly opposed fascism with their core, rose up and took arms against them when it became too much. Those were the partisans and their civilian allies in the cities and villages. And thousands and thousands died fighting the fascists alongside the Soviet communists. And that is the only thing that worked.

    Commenting on a website will never defeat fascism. If the “holy institutions” of democracy and liberalism failed, how could a silly tiny insignificant postboard succeed?












  • How is it cultural genocide when they have all public things (signs, documents etc) written in Mandarin and the local language? If the government rebuilds and renovates historical and religious buildings? Sponsors cultural events, like festivals, parades, performances etc.

    This is true for all autonomous and minority regions and cultures in China btw, not just Xinjiang and the Uyghur people.

    What do you mean by cultural genocide exactly?





  • We might “be” predators, but we didn’t evolve to be predators. At least not obligatory predators like tigers.

    There’s no good evidence that shows meat from hunting was a major part of our diet for 99% of our evolutionary history.

    The vast majority of ancient humans found subsisted mostly on fruits, tubers, grain etc.

    It’s likely we started eating more meat only during the past ice age.

    We’re more like bears than tigers.


  • All great answers. But there’s something people are missing, and it’s a trap created by modern neo-liberal economic thinking.

    Humans are not perfectly rational entities. Capital is not an external alien force that is perfectly rational either (yet). It moves and is brought to life by human hands.

    The ruling forces at the moment are losing their grip. They are desperate. Somethings ARE running away from them.

    They are acting irrationally all the time. They are shooting themselves on the foot, over and over. This is one of those things imo.



  • I mean there were actually two “intelligence” explosions for humans, once as Homo Erectus like 2 million years ago. Then again as Homo Heidelbergensis ~ 700,000 years ago. So way before dogs.

    As in we have evidence of H. Erectus with brains as big or even bigger than ours. And by the time of H. Heidelbergensis our brains stabilised around the size they are today.