Belsan and Dubrovka were humiliating disasters. “Mmm yes, let’s fill a packed theater with fentanyl gas and kill 132 hostages through asphyxiation and choking to death on their own tongues.”
“Our multiple day siege of the school has failed and the Chechens are becoming violent and delirious because of the meth they’re on and dehydration; over 150 children and their parents are already dead due to heatstroke, dehydration, and being shot? Let’s storm the school with tanks, BMPs and RPGs killing hundreds more!” Even though the terrorists had agreed to accept an official negotiation party and relief supplies scheduled just a handful of hours after the disastrous assault was launched. No need to wait for that and see if it brings any results!”
Do try to read a bit more about Dubrovka at least. The terrorists there had multiple bombs and not only have refused negotiations - they gunned down the police officer who went to negotiate and offered to take place of the hostage
They didn’t want to die, the suicide vests were insurance. They never intended to actually detonate any of the bombs. They would never release hundreds of hostages if they wanted a high death toll.
I have no idea where you got any of this information. I really recommend you read more about the crisis, almost nothing you said was true.
What? What police officer? The only person attempting to “negotiate” and was shot was a deranged civilian woman who the terrorists thought was an FSB agent and illegally crossed the police line by herself.
They had accepted several negotiation parties over the course of the four days and expressed multiple times that they didn’t want to kill the hostages, they didn’t want to fight the FSB and GRU and that they were scared. They also immediately released hundreds of people who needed medical attention, were pregnant, were children, or were foreign without any demands and without prompting. They let the audience make phone calls and speak with loved ones, pray, use a designated bathroom area, speak with the news, and walk around the theater.
Where did you read that they refused negotiations? Their first demand was to speak to a Duma member, FSB officer, and Red Cross representatives as a negotiation party, for which they were willing to release hostages. The party arrived, negotiations were held, and the agreed hostages were released. There were negotiations on every day of the siege.
Russian authorities held talks with the hostage takers. The hostage-takers demanded to talk with Iosif Kobzon, a parliament member and singer who has performed songs lauding Chechnya, and with International Red Cross representatives. Four people, including a man waving some white fabric like a flag, entered the building about 1:20pm Shortly thereafter, a man in his 60s, appearing feeble and distraught left the theatre. The Interfax news agency identified him as a British citizen, but did not provide details. A woman and three children, believed to be Russians, were let out a few minutes later.
as previously mentioned they also said that if government representatives were sent to negotiate that they would release more hostages. Which they did,multiple times*.
They would have absolutely surrendered if the negotiations continued. There was absolutely no need to launch a moronic raid that killed 132 people when the terrorists had only killed 3 people. Great return on investment right?
Do you really think the extraordinarily stupid plan was necessary? The terrorists were armed with gas masks, all the gas did was blind them while killing the audience members.
Eh, this one is reasonable.
Belsan and Dubrovka were humiliating disasters. “Mmm yes, let’s fill a packed theater with fentanyl gas and kill 132 hostages through asphyxiation and choking to death on their own tongues.”
“Our multiple day siege of the school has failed and the Chechens are becoming violent and delirious because of the meth they’re on and dehydration; over 150 children and their parents are already dead due to heatstroke, dehydration, and being shot? Let’s storm the school with tanks, BMPs and RPGs killing hundreds more!” Even though the terrorists had agreed to accept an official negotiation party and relief supplies scheduled just a handful of hours after the disastrous assault was launched. No need to wait for that and see if it brings any results!”
Do try to read a bit more about Dubrovka at least. The terrorists there had multiple bombs and not only have refused negotiations - they gunned down the police officer who went to negotiate and offered to take place of the hostage
They also had suicide bombers.
They didn’t want to die, the suicide vests were insurance. They never intended to actually detonate any of the bombs. They would never release hundreds of hostages if they wanted a high death toll.
The lot of other bombs in building weren’t enough of insurance?
I have no idea where you got any of this information. I really recommend you read more about the crisis, almost nothing you said was true.
What? What police officer? The only person attempting to “negotiate” and was shot was a deranged civilian woman who the terrorists thought was an FSB agent and illegally crossed the police line by herself.
They had accepted several negotiation parties over the course of the four days and expressed multiple times that they didn’t want to kill the hostages, they didn’t want to fight the FSB and GRU and that they were scared. They also immediately released hundreds of people who needed medical attention, were pregnant, were children, or were foreign without any demands and without prompting. They let the audience make phone calls and speak with loved ones, pray, use a designated bathroom area, speak with the news, and walk around the theater.
Where did you read that they refused negotiations? Their first demand was to speak to a Duma member, FSB officer, and Red Cross representatives as a negotiation party, for which they were willing to release hostages. The party arrived, negotiations were held, and the agreed hostages were released. There were negotiations on every day of the siege.
https://www.smh.com.au/world/chechen-rebels-release-some-hostages-20021024-gdfr7x.html
as previously mentioned they also said that if government representatives were sent to negotiate that they would release more hostages. Which they did,multiple times*.
They would have absolutely surrendered if the negotiations continued. There was absolutely no need to launch a moronic raid that killed 132 people when the terrorists had only killed 3 people. Great return on investment right?
Do you really think the extraordinarily stupid plan was necessary? The terrorists were armed with gas masks, all the gas did was blind them while killing the audience members.