the ‘orthodox’ movements emerged from the ashkenazi so the ones in palestine are zionist, but there’s a variety of views on the state and violence—some don’t like the state because its too secular, some actually oppose the violence on palestinians, some want to get all the benefits of being settlers without raising arms.
i don’t know what you’d call groups that migrated to palestine and live in the zionist state other than zionist? just settlers? the great many orthodox outside israel it makes sense to not call zionist but it gives me some pause talking about groups inside israel.
but i didn’t mean to imply orthodox sects were exclusive to ashkenazi ancestry, just that it came from eastern europe so its presence in palestine is related to zionism, even though its more diverse now
I don’t have hard numbers for you, but there hasn’t been large scale haredi migration to Israel since around the 50s, that is, 70-80 years ago. Most of the Haredi in Israel now were born there, we’re talking about the kids and grandkids of settlers for the most part. Haredi tend to kinda stay in place, see New York.
Zionists settling and colonizing Israel of course is pretty recent, but huge chunk of the haredi there were born there at this point as I mentioned in another comment. We’re talking about the kids and grandkids of settlers for the most part. Most of the people going to Israel these days though are reform/conservative Jews.
I’m from the USA. There’s plenty of white people here descended from settlers that I wouldn’t call settlers themselves, although settler culture is a still pervasive through the legacy of white supremacy. But yeah, it’d be disingenuous if I said oh every white person in the PSL believes in manifest destiny or something. For lack of a better analogy.
What I mean to say by all this is I only commented because it was an overgeneralization, anti-zionism is a defining characteristic of haredi Jews so it was just a little jarring to read. Certainly they aren’t anti-zionists for the same reasons as you or I, but still
i actually think that is a pretty good analogy, embracing a genocidal ideology of manifest destiny/zionism is different from simply being in a settler state but articulating it takes more specificity.
Technically alot of Palestinians are secretly Samaritans who converted to Islam apparently and technically the Samaritans are actually the best monotheists because they didn’t get sucked into the Jerusalem power struggle even when it first started. I’d love to be corrected lol.
Aren’t many of them descendants of Jews who lived peacefully in Palestine before Zionist settlement?
the ‘orthodox’ movements emerged from the ashkenazi so the ones in palestine are zionist, but there’s a variety of views on the state and violence—some don’t like the state because its too secular, some actually oppose the violence on palestinians, some want to get all the benefits of being settlers without raising arms.
Most Haredim are not zionist.
Edit: and not all Haredim are Ashkenaz either… Especially in Israel. There’s Sephardic and Mizrahi haredim as well.
Edit 2: are you Jewish? This is just straight up false.
i don’t know what you’d call groups that migrated to palestine and live in the zionist state other than zionist? just settlers? the great many orthodox outside israel it makes sense to not call zionist but it gives me some pause talking about groups inside israel.
but i didn’t mean to imply orthodox sects were exclusive to ashkenazi ancestry, just that it came from eastern europe so its presence in palestine is related to zionism, even though its more diverse now
deleted by creator
I don’t have hard numbers for you, but there hasn’t been large scale haredi migration to Israel since around the 50s, that is, 70-80 years ago. Most of the Haredi in Israel now were born there, we’re talking about the kids and grandkids of settlers for the most part. Haredi tend to kinda stay in place, see New York.
Zionists settling and colonizing Israel of course is pretty recent, but huge chunk of the haredi there were born there at this point as I mentioned in another comment. We’re talking about the kids and grandkids of settlers for the most part. Most of the people going to Israel these days though are reform/conservative Jews.
I’m from the USA. There’s plenty of white people here descended from settlers that I wouldn’t call settlers themselves, although settler culture is a still pervasive through the legacy of white supremacy. But yeah, it’d be disingenuous if I said oh every white person in the PSL believes in manifest destiny or something. For lack of a better analogy.
What I mean to say by all this is I only commented because it was an overgeneralization, anti-zionism is a defining characteristic of haredi Jews so it was just a little jarring to read. Certainly they aren’t anti-zionists for the same reasons as you or I, but still
i actually think that is a pretty good analogy, embracing a genocidal ideology of manifest destiny/zionism is different from simply being in a settler state but articulating it takes more specificity.
So is ultra-orthadox ≠ haredim?
Ultra-Orthodox is a very broad and arguably very artificial term for a wide variety of Jewish groups with very different views.
Technically alot of Palestinians are secretly Samaritans who converted to Islam apparently and technically the Samaritans are actually the best monotheists because they didn’t get sucked into the Jerusalem power struggle even when it first started. I’d love to be corrected lol.